Bennett: How to Master Conflict Resolution and Build A High-Performing Team

Feb. 27, 2024
Tips for getting to the bottom of challenges when interpersonal communication breaks down.

Internal conflict is inevitable in any team. It often stems from diverse personalities, competing goals, and the high-pressure shop environments in which our teams operate. However, the ability to effectively mediate and resolve these conflicts doesn't just preserve harmony, it cultivates a high-performing culture. By actively fostering an atmosphere where you address challenges constructively and collaboratively, leaders enhance productivity and strengthen the resilience and unity of their teams. This skill set, therefore, is not merely an asset but a critical component in the toolkit of anyone aiming to lead a business to its fullest potential. 

Building on the foundational understanding that effective conflict resolution is essential to achieving a high-performing culture, it becomes imperative for shop owners to equip themselves with a structured, thoughtful approach to navigating disputes within their teams. The journey from recognizing the conflict to mastering mediation and conflict resolution is both challenging and rewarding. By adopting a process emphasizing preparation, open communication, and collaborative problem-solving, shop owners can turn conflict into a catalyst for team cohesion and innovation.  

It's important to remember that the goal is not just to resolve disagreements but to foster an environment where every team member feels heard, valued, and motivated to contribute to the organization's collective success. 

Here are the critical elements to successfully navigating conflict resolution: 


Have a Deep Understanding 

Understand the Conflict. Leading discussions and setting the stage for healthy and productive outcomes is the first step to gaining clarity on the situation yourself. For instance, if two team members disagree on a project's direction or priorities, I'll listen to each person's perspective to understand the situation from their viewpoint. This step ensures I'm fully informed before bringing the parties together to begin the process of bridging the gap in the disagreement. 


Create a Safe and Neutral Environment 

Choose a Neutral Setting. Choosing a quiet, off-site setting where all parties feel less distracted, comfortable, and less stimulated by the environment is key. A neutral site encourages openness, away from the daily work environment's pressures. 

Set Ground Rules. I would set clear guidelines, such as speaking one at a time and prohibiting personal attacks. This approach has been very practical in a past situation to maintain focus on the issue rather than allowing the conversation to devolve into frustrations and negative talk. 

Get Clear on the Win. Before jumping into discussions and allowing participants to get entrenched in their positions, get everyone to discuss an "ideal outcome." Get clear on the "win, win, win" for everyone involved. This step doesn't assume a one-size-fits-all solution but acknowledges that each conflict has unique resolutions that can satisfy all parties. If finding a clear, ideal outcome is a challenge, lean on your company's mission and values statements to clarify what we should be trying to achieve. By identifying an ideal outcome at the outset, the mediation and resolution process becomes more structured, with a clear objective that guides the subsequent discussion and problem-solving phases. It helps ensure that the dialogue is constructive, focusing on achieving outcomes that address the needs and concerns of all parties involved. 


Facilitate Open Communication 

Emphasizing your role as an active listener means fully engaging with each person's comments without formulating a response while they're speaking. This technique will help you understand underlying issues in a previous conflict. 

Encourage team members to use "I feel" statements to express their feelings, which promotes ownership of emotions and reduces defensiveness, making it easier to find a resolution. It is really hard for someone else to dispute how you feel or how a situation or action made you think. In contrast, statements such as “you’re being rude” are statements of opinion and do invite a defensive response. 


Solve the Problem 

The key to shifting a potentially confrontational discussion into a collaborative effort lies in the ability to highlight shared objectives and values. For instance, in disputes concerning resource allocation, emphasizing the collective goal of project success can transform the perspective of involved parties. This approach redirects the focus from individual grievances to the larger picture, facilitating a mindset where collaboration becomes the preferred path forward. It's not just about finding a middle ground but about reminding everyone of the ultimate goal that unites them, thereby creating a foundation for mutual understanding and respect.  


Brainstorm Solutions Together 

Encouraging each party to contribute potential solutions is critical in harnessing the group's collective intelligence. This process democratizes problem-solving, giving each individual a stake in the outcome and recognizing the value of diverse perspectives. Instead of imposing a top-down resolution, this method fosters a sense of ownership among team members, as they are actively involved in crafting the solution. The brainstorming phase is crucial for uncovering innovative compromises that might not have been apparent initially. It’s a testament to the idea that the sum of a team's problem-solving capabilities can far exceed the individual parts, leading to solutions that are both inclusive and effective in addressing the needs of all parties involved. 


Develop an Action Plan 

After identifying a solution, get an agreement and clear understanding of the specifics of the action or resolution plan. Outline who will do what and by when. Having a clear action plan gains clarity for everyone, which prevents the issue from resurfacing and shows the team that conflicts can be resolved constructively. Schedule a follow-up meeting a few weeks later, allowing everyone to assess the solution's effectiveness and adjust as needed, ensuring long-term resolution and accountability. 

Following these key elements and having a conflict resolution process is a win-win situation for you as the leader and for your team. Fostering a work environment where diversity of thought is accepted and celebrated will trickle down into customer interactions and overall shop success.  

The path to resolving conflicts might be challenging at first, but the payoff is a high-performing team that operates on a foundation of trust and views every challenge as a chance for growth and every conflict as an opportunity to strengthen its bonds. A team like this reaches its highest potential. 

Good luck navigating tensions within your teams! If you’d like to discuss it further, I’d love to talk with you. Feel free to contact me at [email protected]

Sponsored Recommendations

Free Resources for Shops Like Yours

View insights, research and solutions curated specifically for shops like yours.

Restore & Protect: The Powerful Revenue and Profit Accelerator for Your Business

Restore & Protect is a major business opportunity for Valvoline installers with positive impact on profit growth as well as customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Deliver a First-Class Guest Experience

Our dedicated Valvoline Trusted Advisor Sales and Support Team provides hands-on classroom and targeted in-store coaching to help your employees become more skilled at selling...

Promote Growth on Two Fronts: Existing and New Customers

Increase Sales and Customer Traffic To Your Store(s).