Numbers: Pay Plans' Effect on Efficiency

Oct. 26, 2022

Is it true that a flat rate leads to the most efficient and productive technicians? Let's go inside the data.

One of the longest and most contentious debates in the repair industry centers around technician pay. Mainly, which type of pay plan is going to lead to the most successful business? Now “success” can mean many different things. From KPI measurement to fostering a strong culture amongst employees to customer satisfaction. 

Isolating for just one factor, efficiency, the 2021 Ratchet+Wrench Industry Survey found there is a clear difference between shops that use a flat rate and shops that use anything else. 

How do you pay your technicians?

  • Flat rate - 25%
  • Salary - 9%
  • Hourly - 28%
  • Hourly plus commission - 20%
  • Salary plus commission - 5%
  • Other - 13%

Average technician efficiency of shops based on pay plan

% of shops with less than 100 percent efficiency

  • Flat rate - 49%
  • Salary - 66%
  • Hourly - 72%
  • Hourly plus commission - 62%
Is it true that a flat rate leads to the most efficient and productive technicians? Let's go inside the data.
About the Author

Chris Jones | Editor

Chris Jones is Group Editorial Director for the Vehicle Repair Group at Endeavor Business Media. He’s a multiple-award-winning editor and journalist and a certified project manager now providing editorial leadership and brand strategy for the auto care industry's most trusted automotive repair publications—Ratchet+Wrench, Modern Tire Dealer, National Oil & Lube News, FenderBender, ABRN, Professional Distributor, PTEN, Motor Age, and Aftermarket Business World.

Sponsored Recommendations

Valvoline Partner Solutions

We arm you with products that build trust, tools that unlock productivity, and training that drives business performance, so you feel confident in where your...

Grow the business you know

Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.

Solutions that drive results

Connect with Valvoline experts to increase operational efficiency and customer loyalty – from Valvoline-funded promotions to hands-on training, we’re here to...

Free Resources for Shops Like Yours

View insights, research and solutions curated specifically for shops like yours.