Majority of U.S. Drivers Struggle to Afford Unexpected Car Repairs, Survey Finds

A recent Midas survey reveals that 66% of U.S. drivers cannot afford a $500 unexpected car repair, highlighting widespread financial stress and delayed maintenance, especially among millennials and women.

Two-thirds of U.S. drivers would not be able to afford an unexpected $500 car repair, according to the first-ever Midas Consumer Pulse Survey.

As shared in a recent press release, the Midas Consumer Pulse Survey included the following key findings:

U.S. Drivers Are Facing Financial Pressures

  • 66% of drivers would not be able to afford an unexpected $500 repair:
  • 21% say they honestly don't know how they'd handle it
  • 20% would put it on a credit card and pay it off over time
  • 14% would delay the repair as long as possible
  • 11% would borrow from family or friends
  • 51% of drivers report moderate to extreme financial pressure from owning and maintaining a vehicle, and 28% call it "extreme pressure, a real hardship."
  • Middle-income drivers are feeling it too: Only about 1 in 5 drivers earning $50K–$75K could cover a surprise $500 repair without financial stress, no better than drivers overall (19%). And 31% of those earning $75K–$99K would put it on a credit card.
  • Millennial drivers (ages 35–44) are the most stretched: 71% would struggle to pay an unexpected $500 repair, and they're the most likely age group to say a payment plan matters when choosing a shop (26%).
  • Women feel it more: 26% say a $500 bill would be a serious problem vs. 14% of men.

Drivers Are Delaying Maintenance and Taking Repairs into Their Own Hands

  • 53% have delayed or skipped recommended maintenance in the past year, and half of those say it's because they can't afford it.
  • 39% say rising costs have led them to skip or delay services they know they need.
  • The services most often postponed when money is tight are oil changes (33%), tires (32%), and A/C repair (31%).
  • 37% have attempted DIY repairs they'd normally take to a shop, rising to 46% among 25–34-year-olds.
  • When a warning light comes on, the most common first response (33%) is to research a self-fix on Google, YouTube, or AI, ahead of scheduling service right away (23%).

Trust Remains Key for Vehicle Repairs

  • Trust and reputation (51%) is the top factor in choosing a shop, ahead of lowest price (47%) and transparency before work begins (45%).
  • 43% trust a family- or friend-recommended mechanic most, ahead of dealerships (26%) and national chains (20%).
  • What would get drivers to prioritize maintenance even when money is tight: a clear upfront estimate (42%), a trusted relationship with a mechanic (40%), and flexible payment options (37%).
  • In their own words, drivers describe trust as a mix of expertise ("can they fix it?") and fair treatment ("will they treat me fairly?").

"For most people, their car isn't a luxury. It's how they get to work, pick up their kids, and take care of the people who count on them," said Paul Elliott, VP of marketing at Midas. "Mobility is at the center of everyday life, and what stood out to us in this survey is how many drivers are making tough tradeoffs just to keep moving. Our job is to help them stay on the road with honest advice, clear pricing, and options that fit their budget, so every driver who comes into a Midas leaves feeling confident about the money they spent."

 

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates