Silverstein: The Shop Coach Gold Rush

Not everyone selling a “proven system” has the experience to back it up.

Apparently, the repair industry’s latest growth opportunity isn’t fixing cars. It’s coaching the people who fix cars. Frankly, the internet is lousy with them.

The pitch is familiar: tired of struggling? Want a better shop? A shop that runs itself while you spend more time with your family? There’s a coach for that. Possibly several. They’ve got “proven systems” and lots of testimonials from “struggling shop owners just like you.”

Some of these advisers have earned their place. They’ve run shops, made payroll, dealt with employee issues, faced an ugly month, and learned that “just raise your labor rate” is not a viable business plan. Their advice has a real chance of helping.

Then there are people whose experience in shop ownership seems to begin and end with selling services to shop owners. Maybe they’ve read some books and watched some webinars. Maybe they’ve noticed that we shop owners are busy, stressed, and often looking for help. We’re a tempting target, especially if you can sell the dream without actually having to manage the business.

The Industry’s Need Creates Opportunity

The irony is hard to miss. Experienced techs are retiring, and their replacements are few and far between. Shops are trying to cover the work with fewer people, keep customers updated, and make the numbers work. Meanwhile, some techs are still eyeing shop ownership. That’s not necessarily foolish. It does mean many new owners will need good, proven advice. Unfortunately, many have trouble separating good advice from a well-crafted pitch.

That’s where the door swings open for the charlatan. Desperation and dissatisfaction are his leverage points into the owner’s wallet. A new or existing owner may not know whether the coach’s “proven system” came from years of running a shop or a weekend spent rearranging some other coach’s material. But the owner does know that he’s desperate to make a change. The coach may promise growth, freedom, and a team that holds itself accountable. The owner gets a website login, a weekly phone call, and the discovery that the capacity for change must begin with him.

Questions Worth Asking

Before buying the promise, ask the questions. Have you owned a repair shop? If so, how long ago? Did it succeed? What did you personally do there? Can you describe a time your advice didn’t work and what correction you made? If the answers seem suspect, the coaching may be the most successful business the coach has ever operated.

A genuine adviser understands that there’s no universal cure for a shop’s problems. Shops differ; owners differ; markets differ. Good coaching starts with the facts, not a prepackaged transformation plan. It helps an owner think clearly, make decisions, and recognize the trade-offs. It doesn’t promise that every shop can become profitable in a quarter.

The industry needs new owners. It needs experienced mentors, too. What it doesn’t need is another layer of people selling certainty to businesses that already have enough real problems. There are enough people with their hands in our pockets.

About the Author

R. Dutch Silverstein

R. Dutch Silverstein

Owner

R. “Dutch” Silverstein, who earned his Accredited Automotive Manager Certificate from AMI, owned and operated A&M Auto Service, a seven-bay, eight-lift shop in Pineville, North Carolina for 26+ years.

 

Dutch was a captain for a major airline earning type ratings in a variety of aircraft including the Boeing 767/757, 737, 200, 300, and 400 series, Airbus 319/320/321, McDonnell Douglas MD80/DC9 and Fokker FK-28 mk 4000 and 1000. After medically retiring, he transitioned his part-time auto repair business into a full-time occupation.

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates