Bennett: Beyond the Pay Plan: Part 2: Remove the Friction
Key Highlights
- Investigate disappointing production before turning to compensation or asking the team to work faster.
- Trace repair orders from inspection through authorization, parts, and completion to find where time is lost.
- Look for recurring delays the team has come to accept, including unclear responsibilities and owner-dependent decisions.
- Choose one meaningful constraint, make a focused change, and check its effect on the whole workflow.
- Invite employees to report obstacles without fear of being dismissed or blamed.
It’s 10:15 on Monday morning, and a technician is standing at the service counter. You notice him as you walk out of your office. A few minutes later, you pass through again, and he’s still there. There are vehicles in the parking lot, work on the schedule, and a production goal the shop needs to hit. From where you’re standing, it looks like somebody needs to get back to work. Then you ask what he’s waiting for.
The parts for his assigned job arrived, but one of them is wrong. Another vehicle is ready, except the repair order doesn’t clearly describe the customer’s concern. The advisor who spoke with the customer is on the phone. The technician could move to a third vehicle, but doing that means changing the dispatch order, and the person who makes that decision is you. You’ve been in your office answering emails.
In the first installment of this series, we looked at why a disappointing production report should start an investigation before it starts a compensation discussion. Now we’re at the next step: finding and removing the obstacles that investigation reveals. Sometimes that requires a significant change. Sometimes it begins with recognizing why a technician is standing at your counter.
The Shop Can Be Busy While the Work Stands Still
Think about the last time you were stuck in interstate traffic. You had somewhere to be. You wanted to get there. Your vehicle was perfectly capable of moving faster. Pressing harder on the accelerator wouldn’t have helped. It’s easy to recognize that limitation from the driver’s seat. It can be harder to see from the office when payroll is climbing and completed hours aren’t keeping pace.
So, we ask for more urgency. The advisor makes another call. The technician starts another inspection. The manager rearranges the schedule. Everyone finds something to do, and the shop gets busier. But the vehicle promised for 3 p.m. may be no closer to leaving.
Some of that activity is necessary. Calling a customer for authorization moves a repair toward completion. Tracking down a delayed part may be exactly what the situation requires. The question is how much of the day gets consumed by repeatedly chasing information, correcting mistakes, or revisiting decisions that should already be settled. That effort has a cost, even when it never appears as a separate line on your financial statement.
Follow One Repair Order Through the Shop
Consider a hypothetical brake repair. The vehicle arrives on time. The technician completes the inspection and submits the findings. The advisor needs clarification before presenting the estimate, but the technician has already moved to another vehicle. By the time they connect, the customer is unavailable.
Authorization comes later that morning. The parts order goes in, but the next delivery won’t arrive until after lunch. When the parts arrive, the technician is halfway through another repair. By the time the brake job resumes, the original delivery commitment is in jeopardy.
Nobody spent the morning deliberately avoiding work. Yet a repair that required a manageable amount of labor occupied much of the day. Now imagine the owner’s response is to offer an additional production bonus. The bonus may be appreciated, but the incomplete inspection notes, delayed customer conversation, and parts timing still need attention. Those are the conditions determining when the technician can do the work.
Following the repair order makes those conditions visible. Instead of asking only how many hours the technician produced, you start asking what happened between inspection, estimate, authorization, parts arrival, and completion. That is where you begin to find time you can recover.
The Delays Everyone Has Learned to Expect
Listen carefully to how your team describes a normal day. “We always have to ask him.” “That information usually isn’t on the ticket.” “We don’t know which one is next until someone tells us.”
Those comments deserve your attention. They describe obstacles people have stopped reporting because they no longer expect them to change.
The friction can begin before a vehicle reaches the bay. There may not be enough approved work available, or the schedule may contain a mix of jobs that don’t match the team’s capabilities. Dispatch can leave one technician overloaded while another waits for a suitable assignment.
Once work begins, missing information, unavailable equipment, and parts problems can interrupt it. At the next handoff, unclear responsibility can leave everyone assuming someone else has taken over.
Quality problems send work backward. A vehicle returns to the bay, consumes capacity, and disrupts commitments already made to other customers.
Meanwhile, unresolved tension between the front counter and the technicians can make people reluctant to ask the questions that would prevent another mistake.
And then there are the decisions that wait for the owner. If every change in priority requires your approval, your availability becomes part of the production process. The shop’s ability to move work depends on whether you’re answering your phone. That arrangement might have worked when the business was smaller. It deserves another look when capable employees are standing still because you’re occupied.
Choose the Constraint That Matters
Once you begin noticing friction, you’ll find plenty of it. Resist the temptation to announce a complete operational overhaul at the next staff meeting. Your team still has vehicles to repair. Give them a specific improvement they can understand, practice, and sustain. In the brake repair example, suppose a review of several jobs shows that estimates repeatedly stall because inspection findings need clarification. Start there. The advisor and technician can agree on what a complete handoff needs to include: a clear finding, supporting documentation, and enough information to explain the recommendation accurately. Then watch what happens.
Do clarification requests decrease? Are estimates ready sooner? Does authorized work reach the bay earlier? Are quality and customer understanding being maintained? If the handoff improves but jobs still wait for parts, you have learned something useful about the next constraint. If the new requirement creates unnecessary documentation without improving decisions, adjust it.
The purpose is to improve the movement of work through the whole shop. Making one step faster has limited value if everything simply piles up at the next one.
Make It Safe to Report What’s Stuck
Your technicians and advisors can help you find these obstacles, but they need to believe that describing a delay will lead to a useful response. If every reported barrier becomes a lecture about excuses, you’ll hear about fewer barriers. They’ll still exist; you’ll just discover them later, often when a customer is waiting.
Ask the team where work repeatedly stops and what would help it move. Be prepared to hear that a decision you control or a process you introduced is part of the problem. You don’t have to accept every proposed solution. You do have to investigate the information. Start with one recurring delay this week. Follow it across several repair orders. Identify who owns the next action and what that person needs to take it. Make one change, then check whether it helped.
The next time you see a technician standing at the counter, you may still need a conversation about how he’s using his time. But first, find out what brought him there. Better production may begin with getting an obstacle out of his way.
In Part 3, we’ll look at how clear standards, timely conversations, and consistent follow-through keep those improvements from disappearing when the shop gets busy.
About the Author
Mike BennettMike Bennett
Mike Bennett has more than three decades in the Independent Auto Repair industry. Mike has been an ASE Master Technician and is the owner of Mike’s KARS Inc. in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. Fully immersed in the industry for his entire professional career as a master technician, shop foreman, general manager, and automotive shop owner, Mike has a unique and broad perspective on the shop owner experience. Mike is able to communicate with real-world experience and a “been there and done that” perspective. As an Alumni shop owner with the Automotive Training Institute, he continues to operate his shop with his wife Shelle. Mike is now a nationally certified executive trainer and he has spent the last 11 years as a full-time business coach with ATI as well as leading two of ATI’s premier shop owner 20 groups as well as the first-in-industry CEO/COO development program.


